We Need To Talk About Jason, Unfortunately
Edition 03 of The Citation asks what day-to-day discrimination actually looks like and explores avenues of addressing the issue.
This edition’s topics include: The impact of “social threat” on speech, the way stereotypes impact language, exploring power and privilege from both an insider and outsider perspective, and digital literacy, among others.
We need to talk about Jason, unfortunately.
Do you know who Nathan Cofnas is? You shouldn’t. The fact that Cofnas has a Wikipedia page is emblematic of a certain type of discrimination that I think is much more familiar to marginalized groups than the loud, crude bigotry that makes its way onto the news.
If you know about Cofnas, it may be because he publicly accused Dr. Jason Arday of plagiarism. Arday later resigned and was found dead following weeks of public scrutiny. (Meanwhile, Cofnas is still being paid for speeches about race). The accuracy of those allegations matters, as does how institutions and the public respond to them. But scrutiny of someone's work does not excuse dehumanizing treatment. And, for the record, Byline Times reported in October that Taylor and Francis had reviewed concerns about Arday’s work and found no reason to add to its existing correction. I bring up this very sad story as an example of how discrimination works in the daily lives of most people, that what most of us deal with from day to day is in fact a challenge to our intellectual legitimacy rather than open vitriol and slurs.
Arday co-authored a book about his experiences as a Black, disabled student and scholar, and parts of his story tie into mine, given I did the exact same thing. But I’m not here just to tie our stories together. No, this edition concerns various aspects of discrimination, and some of the subtle ways it impacts all of us even when it doesn’t rise to the level of what we now colloquially – and often erroneously – call “microaggressions.”
Be it race, gender, ability, language, or what have you, the headlines that reach the mainstream media are many degrees more intense than the irritants we accept and live with but often don’t have the wherewithal to fight. And, these more subtle issues have been researched extensively, and published in journals across academia. So that’s what this edition is about – the quieter forms of discrimination that may be unfamiliar to others. The tentacles stretch much farther, and in this edition, I hope you’ll better understand how challenging and pervasive this always has been.
That’s what we’re going to try to address in this, the third edition of The Citation.
This Brief is free to read and share. Members can explore the full Edition for the research, its limitations, and the questions it raises.
Inside Edition 03
- Social Threat and Its Impact on Speech – Jack Rechsteiner examines whether nonbinary speakers shift their pronunciation depending on how another speaker’s gender identity is described.
- Sounding Like a Stereotype – Dr. Rachel Elizabeth Weissler and Dr. Julie Boland examine how emotional tone shapes listeners’ perceptions of a speaker’s race.
- Grappling with Power and Privilege in the United States – Dr. David Housel reflects on his own experiences as a queer, white TESOL professional and what it takes to challenge discrimination in everyday life.
- Transferable Digital Literacy Knowledge – Dr. Kiersten Greene explores how teachers can build digital literacy knowledge that carries across tools, platforms, and devices–and why meaningful support matters.
- Segregation and Mortality – A Classic by Chiquita A. Collins and David R. Williams examines the relationship between segregation, unequal resources, and mortality among Black Americans.