THIS EDITION: The Brief Dr. Lauri Goldkind Dr. Amany Alkhayat Dr. Dan Villarreal Dr. Johanna Creswell Báez The Classic

Pivot or Perish?

Edition 02 explores how scholars and human services professionals are adapting through digital stewardship, educational tools, and open data—without losing sight of their mission.

Share

What does adapting look like when resources shrink and how do you keep the mission from drifting?

They tell aspiring academics to “publish or perish.” Essentially, to publish in reputable journals to even have a chance at a sustainable academic career. There are plenty of stories around about how unforgiving that career path can be, with some researchers needing extra work just to keep the lights on.

This means, however, that the work they are pressured to publish deserves a wider audience. Yet we’re living in a world where even the basic funding that supports their ability to attempt to publish and not perish is imperiled. We all know that funding has faced cuts, freezes, and threats of further cuts, and the predicted results are dire, far beyond the careers of these scholars. Whether or not you, as a reader, think this impacts you, it absolutely will someday.

When survival starts changing the mission

Academia may be one current target, but nonprofits and other social services agencies are also feeling the financial strain. This isn’t particularly new to mission-driven organizations, and those that have managed to persist through previous difficult circumstances know well that they have to be prepared to pivot. For some, that leads to an upsetting level of “mission drift”—essentially when organizations move away from their professed ideals to address short-term needs. We’ll come back to that in the conclusion.

Many of us remember the Atlantic article from early in the first Trump administration, “The Cruelty is the Point.” I certainly don’t disagree that there are people who rejoice in seeing the results I linked to above, even as the Gates Foundation projected that global child deaths would rise in 2025 for the first time this century.

The defunding is the point. Forcing those with mission- and knowledge-focused ideals to have fewer and fewer options to generate their scholarship and their societal benefits is a direct goal of cutting funding off at the knees. And, once again, whether this is a part of your direct career or not, it will become a part of your life sooner or later.

What a pivot can look like

But merely pointing out a problem is not what we’re trying to do at this publication. I wrote all that to introduce several articles that show what social services professionals and scholars are trying to do with their limited resources in recent years. Sharing these examples is not necessarily an endorsement of all such choices, but a rebuke to the idea that those who have devoted their livelihoods to solving problems are merely going to choose to perish.

This Edition is about what a pivot can look like, even before the funding dries up. Maybe you can learn from these examples as well.

Inside Edition 02

This Brief is free to read and share. Members can explore the full Edition for the research, its limitations, and the questions it raises.